The Solemnity of the Most Holy Trinity — Homily
Sts. Peter & Paul Parish, Haubstadt and Holy Cross Parish, Fort Branch, Indiana — June 11, 2017
Exodus 34, 2 Corinthians 13, John 3
Today we celebrate Trinity Sunday. Are you excited?
At Christmas nostalgia about "what it might have been like" fills our minds, and we await the moment of putting the Christ-child into the manger scene. At Easter we rejoice in the spring colors and flowers, the candle-lit vigil, and the proclamation of the Resurrection. Most of us even feel something (inspiration or consolation) when we are celebrating the Feast of All Saints, All Souls, or Thanksgiving (which is not a Church holiday but State one).
But what about today? Well, I want to make the case that upon hearing “Trinity Sunday,” we might lift up our hearts in consolation because of what this Feast Day means for us. Here is why: 1) an all-powerful God acts unlike powerful human beings; 2) God's perfection of love seems to require a trinity of persons with whom to share it; and 3) God's own trinitarian dimension of life ought to motivate how we live our lives.
First, God doesn't act like a worldly god. This is important. God is all-powerful, uncreated, sovereign, and infinitely beyond everything else in the universe. What would stop such a supreme being from self-centeredness, authoritarianism, or being stingy? Think about it. Smart, charismatic, wealthy men and women throughout history have been far less powerful or rich or supreme than God, and yet have used their position for self-service. Some are doing it now in different corners of the globe. Maybe each of us have fallen prey to it in our own lives from time to time.
Yet we have a God who does not self-serve. We have a God who did not choose to remain alone in his fortitude and might. On the contrary, Moses proclaims the truth of our God for us in the first reading from Exodus 34: “the LORD, a merciful and gracious God, slow to anger and rich in kindness and fidelity.” Merciful. Gracious. Slow to anger. Kind. Faithful. The point here is that although people may become corrupt because of power, God’s power lies in his love.
This yields our second point: God's perfection requires that God loves perfectly, and charity cannot be done on one's own.
Richard of St. Victor developed a beautiful exposition on the love in God in Book Three of his work The Trinity. He writes, “[W]here there is fullness of all goodness, true and supreme charity cannot be lacking. For nothing is better than charity; nothing is more perfect than charity. However,” and this is profound, “no one is properly said to have charity on the basis of his own private love of himself. And so it is necessary for the love to be directed toward another for it to be charity.” Richard of St Victor is arguing that if God is charitable (loving), then it must be perfect love, and it isn’t perfect love if it isn’t shared love. Do we follow? Ok. So, God must be something other than one solitary man sitting alone. However, it isn't enough to love something "lower" than oneself. A hermit cannot be said to love truly if he or she has but a pet or slave but no equal human being in his or her circle. Therefore, Richard of St. Victor continues, “so that the fullness of charity might have a place in that true Divinity, it is necessary that a divine person not lack a relationship with an equally worthy person," In other words, for God to be God, that is, completely perfect, God must love someone as great as God. Through Revelation, we have been told that God is three persons in One God, and so such love as Richard of St. Victor addresses can exist. I would like to go a little further on this point – that God's love must be shared – because it leads us to how we ought to live (which is our third point).
Commenting on Richard of St. Victor, Jesuit Gerlad O’Collins writes, “To be perfect, the human dialogue of mutual love must be open and, in fact, shared with a third person; the love of two persons is thus fused by a third,” who for the Trinity is the Holy Spirit. O’Collins points out the insight of Richard of St. Victor in understanding God’s triune love: “Certainly, in only a pair of persons there would be no one with whom either of the two could share the excellent delights of His pleasure.”
This can be likened to a family. If a man and a woman enjoy the pleasures of true love, how could they possibly convey their delights to the other fully? Would not one’s own delight in that love cloud his or her understanding of the other’s experience? Thus, they share their love with someone else not part of that pair, namely a child(ren). The child(ren) then also returns that love to each of the parents. Further, I wonder if this desire to share the delights between two persons with a third is, in part, why teenage couples and young mothers share photos and videos on social media even while in the presence of the one they love.
When we realize the love found in the relations in God, our understanding of God and of how we operate changes. If God is perfect love, and if we are made in God’s image, then our love should look like God’s love. Cardinal Kasper writes, “True love is not obtrusive; it respects the other’s being other… In becoming one with the other, love creates and grants space to the beloved, in which he or she can become themselves.” Cardinal Kasper points out that this means our love should not be possessive of the other or demanding of the other. Rather, our love should be a gift to the other, a space for that person to become more fully him or herself. Each person of the Trinity—although one in being—doesn’t intrude upon the space that allows each person to remain distinct. The Father gives the Son everything (John 3:35). The Son respects doing the Father's will (Luke 22:42). The Son ascends so that the Holy Spirit can dwell among and within the Church (John 16:7). When we better understand how God loves, we, too, can begin loving more perfectly in our own lives.
I'll conclude with a thought from Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI. He wrote much about God's love, especially found in his encyclical letter Deus Charitas Est ("God is Love"). The Holy Father's comments might give us hope that we can indeed love like our God in whose image we have been created: "Love is possible, and we are able to practice it because we are created in the image of God." And not only is love possible, but love is asked—commanded us by God, and this "'commandment' of love is only possible because it is more than a requirement. Love can be 'commanded' because it has first been given'." John's Gospel reading this weekend tells us what that loves looks like: "for God so loved the world that he gave his only son so that anyone who believes in him might not perish but have eternal life" (John 3:16). It looks, not like a powerful dictator, but a loving servant.
Knowing that this is our God – loving, trinitarian, and in whose image we are created – should give us great joy for lifting up our hearts on this Feast Day of the Most Holy Trinity.
Knowing that this is our God – loving, trinitarian, and in whose image we are created – should give us great joy for lifting up our hearts on this Feast Day of the Most Holy Trinity.